Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Baseball Sheep - Results and Contest Winners!


The Sheep have come home to roost!

I want to thank everyone for entering the contest -- I was hoping for 25-30 entries...and we got 34!  This is one where having more people makes the results better and the game more fun, so all of your entries (even up to the very last-minute!) are much appreciated.

On some of the questions, there was substantial agreement.  On others, you guys were all over the board.  Without further ado, here are the results:

1) The most famous baseball card is ___________.



T206 Honus Wagner 26
1952 Topps Mickey Mantle 7
Ty Cobb 1

This question was the one with the most agreement of any question -- 26 of 34 said the T206 Honus Wagner.  I was surprised that nobody chose the 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey, Jr.

2) A current or former MLB player named "Bill" or "Billy" is __________.



Billy Ripken 13
Bill Buckner 5
Billy Martin 5
Billy Williams 4
Billy Hamilton 3
Billy Butler 2
Bill Madlock 1
Billy Wagner 1

I expected these results to be all Buckner and Williams when I posted it - Ripken never crossed my mind.  But ol' "Rick Face" himself came out on top with over 2x the votes of his nearest competitor.

3) A current MLB catcher is __________.



Buster Posey 16
Yadier Molina 12
Joe Mauer 3
Brian McCann 2
Russell Martin 1

Apparently only the NL catchers matter to you guys.

4) The "junk wax era" ended in this year: __________.



1993 10
1994 7
1995 5
1992 2
1996 2
1999 2
2000 2
2001 1
2002 1
2004 1
2014 1

The exact year is up for debate, but the window of 1992-1996 is fairly well-agreed-upon.  Except for the one who thinks it ended last week.

5) If I could own an MLB team, I would choose this one: __________.




Dodgers 13
Yankees 12
Red Sox 4
Rangers 2
Angels 1
Mets 1
Dustin Pedroia 1

Looks like a little East Coast vs. West Coast battle going on here.  The Dodgers take it by one vote.  However, there was one vote for this team:
(Not a Baseball Team)

6) Name a member of the Boone family that played in the big leagues: __________.



Bob Boone 15
Bret Boone 11
Aaron Boone 6
Ray Boone 2



Look at that family!  You only had four choices on this one, and most of you went with Bob and Bret.

7) A current or former Pittsburgh Pirate player is __________.


Roberto Clemente 16
Andrew McCutchen 14
Willie Stargell 4

You had a lot more possible choices here, but stuck with only 3 different guys.  This was "Sheep" at its finest!  :-)

8) This number is the most iconic record in baseball: __________.



56 15
42 4
61 4
714 2
715 2
755 2
762 2
62 1
300 1
744 1

Dimaggio's 56-game hitting streak took the top spot here, with Jackie's # and the Home-Run records following behind.

9) The ideal baseball card set should have this many cards in it: __________.



792 11
660 6
300 4
750 2
200 1
220 1
250 1
330 1
400 1
600 1
661 1
752 1
762 1
881 1
900 1

The fans of the Topps overproduction sets came out in force here.

10) When going to a baseball game, I buy this many beers: __________.



2 16
0 7
3 6
1 3
5 1
6 1

The good news...only 2 of my blog readers are those drunk guys screaming in the 4th inning.  For everyone who answered 2 beers, that'll only cost you 28 dollars.

11) The greatest third-baseman of all time is: __________.



Mike Schmidt 17
Brooks Robinson 10
George Brett 3
Archi Cianfrocco 1
Cal Ripken 1
Chipper Jones 1
Wade Boggs 1

"The Human Vacuum Cleaner" made it close, but Schmidt took this one. 

12) A team in the American League West is __________.



Angels 12
A's 9
Rangers 8
Mariners 4
Astros 0
Yankees 1

 One of these things is not like the other....

13) The best "role model" in baseball right now is: __________.



Derek Jeter 14
Mike Trout 6
Clayton Kershaw 4
David Wright 2
Matt Kemp 2
Andrew McCutchen 1
Jim Thome 1
Ken Griffey Jr. 1
Miguel Cabrera 1
R.A. Dickey 1
Torii Hunter 1

I'll teach my kids to be like Derek - always make sure you give your conquests some autographed memorabilia.

14) The most I would spend on one World Series ticket for my favorite team is __________.








$200 8
$100 7
$500 6
$250 3
$300 2
$350 2
$15 1
$25 1
$125 1
$150 1
$400 1
$1,000 1

Only $15 for the World Series?  I've spent more than that for Spring Training.  :-)

15) The age at which girls become more important than baseball cards for a card-collecting boy is __________.



13 12
15 8
14 6
16 5
12 1
17 1
25 1

16) A pitcher in the 2013 All-Star game was __________.



Clayton Kershaw 14
Mariano Rivera 10
Justin Verlander 3
Max Scherzer 3
Yu Darvish 3
Matt Harvey 1

Even Rivera's final All-Star game appearance wasn't enough to top Clayton.

17) The most-poorly-run franchise in baseball is: __________.



Marlins 14
Astros 7
Cubs 4
Mets 4
Royals 3
Dodgers 1
Mariners 1

18) The scariest current or former pitcher for a batter to face: __________.



Randy Johnson 18
Bob Gibson 4
Nolan Ryan 3
Aroldis Chapman 1
Justin Verlander 1
R.A. Dickey 1
Rick Ankiel 1
Roger Clemens 1
Roy Halladay 1
Ryne Duren 1
Sandy Koufax 1
Satchel Paige 1

Randy Johnson vs. John Kruk:


I just learned who Ryne Duren was, too.


19) A baseball team that has blue as one of its team colors is __________.



Dodgers 20
Blue Jays 8
Cubs 4
Mets 1
Yankees 1

Even though they have BLUE in their name, the Jays could only swing 8 votes.

20) I feel cheated if I spend more than this amount for a pack of cards: __________.


$5.00 13
$3.00 11
$2.99 4
$4.99 2
$1.00 1
$4.00 1
$10.00 1
$15.00 1

If all the 99-cent people had rounded up, $3 and $5 would have been tied!  One person only buys Opening Day and Triple Play, I see.

Scoring and Winners:
As I mentioned originally, for each question you get the number of points equal to the number of people who gave the answer you did -- highest score wins.

Without further ado, our winners are:  TTG and The Lost Collector!!!  The local Dodger-bloggers (Stealing Home and Greg Z) were close in 3rd and 4th. 

Here's what we have for the standings:

TTG (Joe) - fromanunlikelysource 254
The Lost Collector 245
Stealing Home/All Trade Bait All The Time 244
Greg Z/Plaschke, Thy Sweater Is Argyle 240
Daniel/It's like having my own Card Shop 231
Steve D. 230
Josh D / Royals and Randoms 226
Nachos Grande 225
Scott O 221
The Diamond King 219
Dhoff / Coot Veal and the Vealtones 218
Thoughts And Sox 213
RAZ @ The Raz Card Blog 210
Great Sports Name Hall of Fame 210
TorontoBlueJaysCollection 208
Alex M/Chavez Ravining 207
Jeff - One Man's Junk (Wax) 207
Stubby--stubbyschristmas 207
Nick P./Dime Boxes 206
Matt / Tenets of Wilson 203
rnisly 202
hockeykazi 197
Zach from Autographed Cards 193
Tribecards 192
Kerry B / Cards on Cards 185
Marcus 184
Gavin at Baseball Card Breakdown 177
Play at the Plate 169
Bleedin' Brown and Gold 166
captkirk42 164
Robin 153
The Junior Junkie 139
Dawgbones/Schmidt Happened! 127
John H 98
  
I also said I would give one prize to a random participant.  Thank you to those who promoted the contest on your blog....I have double-entered you here.  The traditional 3 spins of the randomizer yields....The Junior Junkie!  Congrats!

I would love to run this game again in the future.  Thanks to everyone who entered.  If you have any comments about how this ran, or if you have any good ideas for future questions, please post them in the comments below. 

























10 comments:

  1. Awesome game. I don't have any questions to offer up, but would definitely play again in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fun contest -- and entertaining write-up. Thanks to which ever responder voted to own Dustin Pedroia for making me laugh.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Congrats to the winners. That was fun. I got some of them right. It is a lot harder when you are trying to answer the way someone else would. For some of the questions I wouldn't even think of the answers I eventually came up with or the ones that "won".

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yay! That's a blessing because I got SO MANY WRONG. Thanks for the contest!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm so bummed that I missed participating, but it was awesome seeing the responses.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow - I missed it by one point! Sheesh!
    Thanks for a fun contest. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Lots of fun. Great concept.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks to all for your kind words! Glad you enjoyed it.

    ReplyDelete

Have something to say?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...